Whistleblowing

What is Whistleblowing?

Whistleblowing occurs when a current or former employee raises concerns about illegal, harmful, or unethical conduct within a company or organization. This can include corruption, abuse of power, violations of employee rights, threats to public health, neglect of care, or damage to the environment. Find out what is whistleblowing and how its regulation differs with us.

The term whistleblowing comes from the phrase “to blow a whistle,” which metaphorically means calling out a foul, much like a referee blowing a whistle in sports. Whistleblowing is often viewed as a test of trust and ethical culture within an organization.

Want to see how Sloneek can help you with whistleblowing? Take a look at our Trust Box module.

The Significance and Value of Whistleblowing

What is whistleblowing in business? It applies across various areas of organizational management, from public administration and health and social care to private enterprise. Whistleblowing is crucial for protecting patients, clients, employees, and the public. It helps uncover conduct that might otherwise remain hidden and strengthens transparency, accountability, and fairness.

From an ethical standpoint, what is whistleblowing in ethics? It represents an employee’s display of moral courage and responsibility toward society, often at personal risk. For businesses, whistleblowing is an effective tool that helps prevent legal issues, financial losses, and reputational damage. It also fosters a corporate culture built on trust and open communication.

In specialized sectors, the role of whistleblowing is even more critical. What is whistleblowing in nursing and what is whistleblowing in healthcare are essential for ensuring patient safety and quality care. Similarly, what is whistleblowing in care focuses on protecting vulnerable individuals from neglect or abuse, ensuring compliance with Child protection/abuse procedures.

Corporate Obligations and the EU Whistleblowing Directive

Under the EU Whistleblowing Directive (Directive 2019/1937) of the European Parliament and Council on the protection of persons who report misconduct, companies and public institutions are required to establish internal reporting systems that enable employees to safely submit reports.

A critical component of this system is the Whistleblowing Policy. What is a whistleblowing policy? It is an internal document that outlines procedures for submitting, investigating, and evaluating whistleblowing disclosures. This often includes what is a whistleblowing hotline — a dedicated communication channel for confidential reporting, or an online form that ensures anonymity and protection for the whistleblower.

The key role in the whistleblowing process is played by a designated person (sometimes called an ombudsman or Monitoring Officer), who receives and handles the reports. This can be someone within the HR department, an external auditor, or a member of the Policy Committee. Important regulatory bodies such as the Financial Conduct Authority, Care Quality Commission, and Health and Safety Executive also play vital roles in handling external whistleblowing cases and providing support systems.

Legal Framework in the United States

In the United States, whistleblower protections are governed by various federal and state laws. Public servants in the federal government are protected by laws allowing them to report waste, fraud, and abuse to an Inspector General without risking their security clearance or employment status.

The Whistleblower Protection Act of 1989 provides federal employees the right to make whistleblowing disclosures and ensures protection from retaliation. This framework ensures that those who speak out in the public interest are shielded from adverse consequences.

Legal Protections in the UK

In the United Kingdom, whistleblowing protections are primarily governed by the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998 (PIDA), which amended the Employment Rights Act 1996. The Public Interest Disclosure Act protects workers from detrimental treatment if they blow the whistle on wrongdoing in the public interest.

A disclosure is protected if it relates to a criminal offence, a breach of a legal obligation, endangering health and safety, damage to the environment, a miscarriage of justice, or a deliberate cover-up of any of these matters. Organizations like Health Education England provide guidance on National Whistleblowing Standards to help ensure proper procedures are followed.

Internal and External Whistleblowing

There are two main types of whistleblowing:

1. Internal Whistleblowing: This occurs when an employee reports misconduct to someone within their organization, such as a manager, the HR department, or through a designated confidential reporting channel. Many companies have a Grievance Policy, Bullying and Harassment Policy, or Harassment procedures that can be used for this purpose. An internal audit team may also investigate such reports.
2. External Whistleblowing: This involves reporting wrongdoing to an outside organization, such as a government agency, regulatory bodies, the media, or law enforcement. This is often done when internal channels have failed or are not trusted. In the US, employees can report to an Inspector General, while in the UK, reports may be made to bodies like the Financial Conduct Authority or Care Quality Commission.

Whistleblower Programs and Support Systems

To encourage reporting, many organizations are implementing whistleblower programs. These programs often include digital systems for confidential reporting, sometimes referred to as Cyber Whistleblowing. These systems must have robust privacy protections to safeguard the identity of the whistleblower.

Support for whistleblowers is crucial. Organizations must provide clear contact details and email addresses for reporting, along with access to a legal representative if needed. The EU Directive and National Whistleblowing Standards set benchmarks for how organizations should handle whistleblowing disclosures.

Proper handling of whistleblowing contributes to better employee well-being and employee morale. A well-drafted Whistleblowing Report should follow established procedures and may reference Child protection/abuse procedures or Harassment procedures where applicable.

Criticism of Whistleblowing

Whistleblowing also has its critics. Some view it as a threat to loyalty toward the employer or a tool that can be misused for personal attacks or revenge. There are also concerns about eroding trust within the company and creating tense workplace relationships. Moreover, whistleblowers often fear retaliation or job loss, even though they are legally protected.

This is why it is crucial to have a clear Whistleblowing Policy that guarantees anonymity, fair assessment, and protection for all parties involved. An unauthorized disclosure of national security information can have severe legal consequences, so it is important that whistleblowers have access to the right information and legal advice.

Summary

Whistleblowing is an important tool that protects the public interest, promotes ethical behavior, and increases organizational accountability. Thanks to the EU Whistleblowing Directive (Directive 2019/1937), the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998, and clearly defined internal policies, whistleblowers can be confident that their reports will be objectively investigated and that they will be protected from retaliation.

Effective whistleblowing systems not only help prevent criminal offences and breaches of legal obligations, but also protect national security, public health, and patient safety. The Policy Committee, Monitoring Officer, and internal audit team often oversee these processes to ensure compliance and fairness. Ultimately, a strong whistleblowing culture contributes to better employee well-being, employee morale, and organizational integrity.